top of page

“I’m Not Going!”: A Guide to Managing Resistant Teens Over the Holidays

Writer: Pamela Newman, LCSW-C
Pamela Newman, LCSW-C
12 minutes ago
4 min read

“Ugh, I hate going to see my grandparents, they are so frustrating. They just don’t get me and I’m tired of them talking to me like I’m a child!” Annually, around this time of year in my practice, I’ve heard a phrase like this one. Many teens feel that they are being “dragged” to family celebrations where they feel uncomfortable, talked down to, or that they need to act inauthentically in order to make it through the Holidays. 


As a clinician, I know my experience (luckily) was the opposite. I loved spending time with my extended family over the Holidays, but that is not the case for a lot of people. As a parent, it can be a difficult balance between acknowledging their feelings and determining whether this experience will truly be traumatic for them or simply be an annoying evening. 


Obviously, we don’t want to put our children in a situation that will be harmful for them, and at the same time, we also need them to learn and understand that they can tolerate discomfort and survive less-preferred situations without running away from them. Depending on your values surrounding family, this can be a tight line to walk. 


If your teen or tween expresses concern about family gatherings, here are some things you can do to manage these feelings ideally without them screaming and slamming doors: 


Listen empathically: Take the time to listen to their concerns. Truly be curious and try to understand their opinion and perspective on spending time with extended family. Then be sure to mirror and validate what they are feeling. “What I’m hearing from you is (insert their words). I understand that you are feeling (insert their words).” Then, thank them for sharing their thoughts with you. Tell them you need think-time before deciding. Simply saying what many of us would have heard as children, “they are your family! This is important! You are going and that’s final!” will cause them to shut down or act out. 

Anticipate and speak openly: Obviously don’t want until you are about to walk out the door to tell them they are going. If you know they may be reluctant, open a dialogue at least a week before the event. This gives them (and you) time to process.  


Try not to decide when you are emotional yourself. We should avoid making big decisions any time we are emotionally activated as our frontal lobe (the part that controls planning, decision making, and problem solving) is not functioning optimally. We want to give ourselves the opportunity to consider all options calmly before making a choice so we don’t feel more rushed or pressured.  


If it’s a safety issue: If your child truly does not feel safe attending these events for one reason or another, strongly consider not forcing them to go. If your child is concerned regarding feeling bullied, mis-gendered or mis-named, teased regarding neurodivergence or any other difference, be aware of their mental well being and long term impact. When possible, speak to family members to educate them about your child’s concerns and gauge their reactions. Protecting our children is of the upmost importance. 


If it’s simply a less-preferred task, validate and encourage them to attend without utilizing guilt or manipulative tactics. “I completely understand this isn’t fun for you. This year we are going to go. If you still feel the same way next time, we can discuss it then.” It can be tempting to say things like, “Grandma isn’t going to be around much longer…” but resist the urge to do so. Try brainstorming with them: what is one thing that we could do that might make the evening more interesting or enjoyable? Perhaps you could invent a new family tradition that would be fun for years to come. 


“I don’t know what to talk about” – If they are concerned regarding not wanting to discuss things like college admissions, dating, or other potentially awkward topics, try role-playing with them responses to specific topics. Sometimes, when we know what to say, it can alleviate anxiety. You can also consider conversation topics based on who is attending. 


On cellphones: If they are reluctant to attend, be sure to establish clear phone rules with them (such as no phones during meals) prior to leaving (at least 24 hours in advance). Teens will be tempted to numb negative feelings by scrolling social media or playing games on their phone, which will only irritate you or your family members. 


Set a definite end time: Sometimes, knowing there is a set end-time can relieve some anxiety and stress for your teen. Check in with them during the outing to make sure they are managing occasionally while you are there. Make sure if you set the end time, that you stick to it, and don’t spend an extra 20 minutes saying good-byes. 


Ultimately, it can be an extremely tough tightrope to walk when it comes to family gatherings. Especially if you are experiencing mixed feelings about your family. We encourage you to discuss these concerns with a licensed clinician. Your teen could also discuss and brainstorm strategies for managing their concerns in their own therapy session.


"Cousins are the barometers of how fun a family get-together will be." —Jim Gaffigan

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page